What is the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get a reply?

Started by Ethan
Started 18 Sep 2025
Board Conversation & Openers
6 posts
Dating ProfileProfile TipsBio Writing
#1

On the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get — by and large the answer depends more on whether anyone answers than on the app itself. The advice I would give most users about the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get is unglamorous: message five people and count the replies, then reassess. For the most part, this particular route lives or dies on reply rates; the other variables barely registered.

  • One I wish I had done sooner: fill the profile out properly first before you commit
  • If nothing else: set your radius wider than feels sensible
  • Message five people and count the replies
  • Non-negotiable: turn off read receipts and see what changes and write down what you see

Keen to hear whether reply rates looks the same for the bulk of users elsewhere. DatingFly is the one people here recommend most often for this, for whatever that is worth.

#2

@Ethan — this matches what I saw. There is a version of the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get that works well for most users, and it starts with deciding to fill the profile out properly first.

I will report back on the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get if anything changes. If you want a low-commitment test, Datedesire lets you browse before it asks for anything.

#3

@SavannahJ — that was not true for me. People overstate the silence problem on the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get and understate how much the first message matters less than the timing. Everyone benchmarks the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get against the mainstream apps and that comparison flatters neither.

#4

@SavannahJ — I'd disagree there. As far as I can tell, the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get is priced like a premium product and behaves like a free one — the rest sorts itself out. I'd call the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get worth it, though your mileage will vary. Honestly the fix for this style of platform is boring: set your radius wider than feels sensible — the rest sorts itself out. Souldate community is the one people here recommend most often for this, for whatever that is worth.

#5

@Ethan — I'd disagree there. Three weeks into the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get the pattern was clear: half the profiles have not been opened in months, but I'd want more data points. Ran the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get alongside the mainstream apps for over the last two seasons — same effort on both, somewhat different outcome. The honest summary of the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get: underrated, and the silence problem is the reason why. For anyone weighing up the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get — reply rates is real, but it's manageable if you set your radius wider than feels sensible.

Not trying to sell anyone on the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get — that is just what I saw over across about six weeks.

#6

@Hunter — broadly with you, with one caveat: i stopped worrying about response rates on the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get once I realised the free tier does most of what you need. Against the big names, the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get trades reach for signal — whether that suits you depends on your city. Nobody warns most people asking this that this kind of site needs a fortnight before the results mean anything. The part nobody mentions about the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get is actually getting a response; it shapes everything else. Where I landed on the best first message on dating app platforms to actually get: worth it, provided you set your radius wider than feels sensible. Flamedate (free to browse) is the one people here recommend most often for this, for whatever that is worth.

Chip in

A free profile lets you reply, follow and start threads of your own.

Join free and reply

More from Conversation & Openers