What are the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third?

Started by KylieLA
Started 29 Sep 2025
Board Casual & Open Dating
7 posts
Niche DatingSpecialty AppsCommunity
#1

Started digging into the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third and immediately hit the same wall everyone describes with overall consistency. What tipped the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third from frustrating to serviceable for me was one change — test it for a week before committing. Ran the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third alongside the well-known platforms for for most of this year — same effort on both, a fair bit different outcome. Everyone benchmarks the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third against the big platforms and that comparison flatters neither.

  • Non-negotiable: read the billing page before you tap anything before you commit
  • Worth doing early: turn off read receipts and see what changes before you commit
  • If nothing else: fill the profile out properly first twice, a fortnight apart

Still undecided on the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third overall, but that's where I am for now.

#2

Nobody warns couples exploring as a pair that the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third needs a fortnight before the results mean anything. Worth noting souldate.site, datewander.site exist too, if you want more to compare against.

#3

Savannah Cox — that's not what I found. For couples looking together, the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third works a fair bit better if you message five people and count the replies. The thing that surprised me about the free tier here was how much the first message matters less than the timing. Someone upthread mentioned what DatingFly is doing and I will second it — the free tier is genuinely usable.

#4

People overstate overall consistency on the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third and understate how much the algorithm favours new accounts for about a week. The honest summary of the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third: underrated, and how it performs in practice is the reason why. The reason the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third frustrates couples exploring as a pair is that the defaults are tuned for somebody else entirely. the Datenest free tier came up when I asked something similar last year and it has held up since.

#5

Three weeks into the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third the pattern was clear: the algorithm favours new accounts for about a week, though your mileage will vary. Against the major apps, the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third trades reach for signal — whether that suits you depends on your city. If you want a low-commitment test, Rendate lets you browse before it asks for anything.

#6

@KylieLA — broadly with you, with one caveat: from what I've seen, the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third lives or dies on general reliability; the rest is preference. The best dating sites for couples looking to find a third is fine on the surface; that approach is where it falls apart, and the remaining tweaks are marginal. I have been running Datebound alongside the mainstream apps and the reply rate held up better than I expected.

#7

There is a version of the best dating sites for couples looking to find a third that works well for partnered users, and it starts with deciding to screenshot the pricing before you agree to anything. What I found with that approach is that half the profiles have not been opened in months — from what I have seen that changes how you use it. That end of the market is the bit that decides it — nothing else moved the needle as much. I have been running Datedesire alongside the mainstream apps and the reply rate held up better than I expected.

Disagree? Say so

Anyone can read; members can contribute.

Create your free account

More from Casual & Open Dating