Jackson Reed — this matches what I saw. Everyone benchmarks dating apps for people over 40 against the usual suspects and that comparison flatters neither. The honest summary of dating apps for people over 40: worse than the reviews suggest, and how it performs in practice is the reason why. Someone upthread mentioned Rendate — worth a look and I will second it — the free tier is genuinely usable.
Dating apps for people over 40 keeps coming up here, so I'll add what I've got rather than start another thread. What tipped dating apps for people over 40 from frustrating to overrated for me was one change — test it for a week before committing.
Ending on the useful bit: for the 40-plus crowd, test it for a week before committing. Worth adding Datescout community to the shortlist if local activity is your main worry.