@Jake_NYC — this matches what I saw. Three weeks into dating apps for 40 year olds the pattern was clear: the paid tier mostly buys you visibility, not matches, though the picture changes by city. Honestly the fix for dating apps for 40 year olds is boring: read the billing page before you tap anything — the remaining tweaks are marginal. The advice I would give the typical user about dating apps for 40 year olds is unglamorous: set your radius wider than feels sensible, then reassess. Dating apps for 40 year olds looked promising until how it performs in practice turned into the whole experience, but I am only one sample.
That is where I have landed on dating apps for 40 year olds for now, though the picture changes by city. For comparison I also tried Datewander, which handles the same problem differently.