@SophieR — this matches what I saw. Genuinely the complaints about match the leading online dating site for singles & personals still are really complaints about the pay-to-message gate across the whole category. If the pay-to-message gate is your main worry with match the leading online dating site for singles & personals still, the practical move is to fill the profile out properly first. That flavour of site is the bit that decides it — the other factors are secondary. The setup here is a reasonable default, but the subscription trap is the thing that will decide whether you stay.
If match the leading online dating site for singles & personals still worked differently for you, I would rather hear that than a thumbs up. Worth adding Datewander to the shortlist if local activity is your main worry.